|
This stub is a work-in-progress by the ScienceCorruption.com journalists's group. We are indexing the millions of documents stored at the San Francisco Uni's Legacy Tobacco Archive [1] With some entries you'll need to go to this site and type into the Search panel a (multi-digit) Bates number. You can search on names for other documents also. Send any corrections or additions to editor@sciencecorruption.com
|
Alvan L Barach was a Clinical Professor of Medicine. College of Physicians and Surgeons, Columbia Uni, New York who was a tobacco industry helper. He was also a recipient of the CTR Special Projects #4 grants, who elected to be funded in secret. CTR Special Projects
Documents & Timeline
1964 Aug 12 The later science director of the CTR, Sheldon C Sommers was then the Associate Pathologist, Columbia University. He is on a panel set up for the CTR to examine the grant applications by William I Fishbein of the Chicago Board of Health. The panel is made up of Carl C Seltzer and five doctors (MDs), Ross L Mclean, L Henry Garland, Sheldon C Sommers, Alvan L Barach and Caroline Bedell Thomas. Fishbein plans to conduct autopsies on 200 geriatric patients and examine their lungs. [2]
1968 Aug An unidentified article on "emphysema diagnosis" with this date was later included in a list of "Recent Helpful Documents" in Leonard Zahn's files at the CTR. [3]
- [ Leonard Zahn and his wife Hilda ran a science reporting and recruiting business for the tobacco industry.]
1970 March 11 Alvan Barach has written to the editor of the Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA). He complains that the media are constantly frightening the public with medical stories.
Emphysemia, he says, does not cause everyone to die of suffocation (In fact most die of heart failure!), and he suggests that they should recommend that smokers become "non-hinhalers" -- that they continue to smoke, but don't take it down into the lungs.[4]
- [He advised the tobacco industry that this letter had been accepted for publication in JAMA, which suggests that he was now providing services on request]
Court-declared list of scientists
Note: this is just a partial list of the scientists, academics and 'consultants' who were being paid via Special Project accounts. It deals only with the scientists known to the courts at the time it was compiled. Many other academics and professionals were paid via these accounts as revealed at later dates.
The Council of Tobacco Research (CTR) was a tobacco front group designed to promote the idea that science had not proven cigarettes were bad for your health. Those listed below were scientists funded by tobacco to confuse the scientific issues.
Grants made via the CTR's Scientific Advisory Board (SAB) may be legitimate (or not), but those made through the secret Special Account #4 were effectively bribes. |
| UNDATED: But possibly 1975 — INDIVIDUALS OBTAINING SECRET GRANTS THROUGH CTR Special Account #4 |
|---|
| Domingo M Aviado | Lauren V Ackerman | George Albee | James Ballenger |
| Alvan L Barach | Walter L Barker | Broda O Barnes SP#41
W-BRF, Colorado State Uni. | Walter Becker |
| Peter Berger | Rodger L Bick | Theodore H Blau | Richard Bing |
| Evelyn J Bowers | Thomas H Brem | Irvin Blose | Walter M Booker |
| Oliver Brooke | Richard Brotman | Lyman A Brewer SP#47
School of Medicine, USC, LA | Barbara B Brown SP#50
PANA Res.Found., Sepulveda CA |
| K Alexander Brownlee | Katherine Bryant | Victor B Buhler | Thomas H Burford |
| J Harold Burn | Marie Burnett | Maurice Campbell | Duane Carr |
| Rune Cederlof | Domenic V Cicchetti | Martin J Cline | W Clark Cooper |
| Anthony M Cosentino | Daniel Cox | Gertrude M Cox | |
| Geza De Takato | Bertram D Dimmens | Charles Dunlap | Henry W Elliott |
| J Earle Estes | Frederick J Evans | William Evans | Hans J Eysenck SP#60/65
Uni of London, UK. |
| Jack M Farris | Sherwin J Feinhandler | Alvan R Feinstein SP#2
Yale Uni, New Haven, Conn | Herman Feldman |
| Edward Fickes | Theodor N Finley | Melvin W First | Edwin R Fisher |
| Russel S Fisher | Merritt W Foster | Richard Freedman | Herbert Freudenberger |
| Arthur Furst | Nicholas Gerber | Menard M Gertler | Jean D Gibbons |
| Carl Glasser | Donald Goodwin | Bernard G Greenberg | Alan Griffen |
| Finn Gyntelberg | William Heavlin | Norman W Heimstra | Joseph Herkson |
Richard J. Hickey SP#56
Wharton School, U of Penn. | Carlos Hilado | Harold C Hodge | Charles H Hine |
| Gary L Huber | Wilhelm C Hueper | Darrell Huff | Duncan Hutcheon |
| Joseph J Janis | Roger A Jenkins | Marvin Kastenbaum | Marti Kirschbaum |
Leonard A Katz SP#3
Michigan State Uni, East Lansing | Lawrence L Kuper | Mariano La Via | Hiram T Langston SP#4
VA Hospital, Hines IL |
| William G Leaman | Michael Lebowitz | Samuel B Lehrer | William Lerner |
| Edward Raynar Levine | Gerald J Lieberman | Stephen C Littlechild | Eleanor Macdonald |
| Nathan Mantel | Ross McFarland | Thomas F Mancuso SP#67
Occ.Health, Uni of Pittsburgh | Milton Meckler |
| Nancy Mello | Jack Mendelson | Irvin Miller | Marc Micozzi |
| Kenneth M Moser | Albert H Niden | Judith O'Fallon | John O'Lane |
| William B Ober | Joseph H Ogura | Ronald Okun | Ingram Olkin |
| Thomas L Petty | Leslie Preger | Walter J. Priest | Richard Proctor |
| Terrence P Pshler | Herbert L. Ratcliffe | Attilio Renzetti | L.G.S. Rao |
| Raymond H Rigdon | Jay Roberts | Milton B Rosenblatt | John Rosencrans |
| Walter Rosenkrantz | Ray H Rosenman | Linda Russek | Henry Russek |
| Ragnar Rylander | George L Saiger | D.E. Sailagyi | I Richard Savage |
| Richard S Schilling | Stanley S Schor | Gerhard N Schrauzer | Charles Schultz |
| John Schwab | Carl C Seltzer | Paul Shalmy | Robert Shilling |
| Henry Shotwell | Allen Silberberg | N. Skolnik | James F Smith SP#43
Uni of Tennessee, Memphis |
| Louis A. Soloff | Sheldon C Sommers (CTR) | JB Spalding | Charles Spielberg |
| Charles Spielberger | Lawrence Spielvogel | Russell Stedman | Arthur Stein |
| Elia Sterling | Theodor Sterling SP#51/58/61/62
Washington U, St Louis | Thomas Szasz | Paul Toannidis |
| Chris P Tsokos | Helmut Valentin | Richard Wagner | Norman Wall |
| Roger Wilson | Jack Wiseman | George Wright | John P Wyatt |
Jacob Yerushalmy SP#59
SPH UC Berkely+ Stats, Jerusalem | Irving Zeidman | |
| ORGANISATIONS OBTAINING SECRET GRANTS THROUGH CTR Special Account #4 |
|---|
| Aleph Foundation | Arthur D. Little | Aspen Conference | Atmospheric Health Sciences
(Domingo M Avido) |
ACVA Atlantic
(Gray Robertson) | Able-Lands | Battelle Columbus Laboratories | Battelle Memorial Institute |
| Billings & Gussman | BioResearch Laboratories
(L.G.S. Rao) | Brigham Young University | Colucci & Associates |
| Cohen Coleghety Foundation | Code Consultants Inc. | Carney Enterprises | Computerland |
| | Engineered Energy Management | Environmental Policy Institute | Eysenck Institute of Psychiatry
(Hans J Eysenck) |
| Fudenberg | Harvard Medical School | Hine Inc.
(Charles H Hine) | Information Intersciences |
| International Consultancy | International Technology Corporation | International Information Institute | J.B. Spalding Statistical Service |
| J.F. Smith Research Account | Jacob, Medinger & Finnegan | Kravetz Levine & Spotnitz | Shook, Hardy & Bacon |
| Michigan State University | Meckler Engineering Group
(Milton Meckler) | Peat, Marwick Main & Co. | R.W. Andersohn & Assoc. |
| Pitney, Hardin & Kipp | Public Smoking Research Group | Response Analysis Project
(Alfred Vogel/Reuben Cohen) | Response Analysis Corporation
(Alfred Vogel/Reuben Cohen) |
| Schirmer Engineering Corp. | St. George Hospital & Medical School | Stanford Research Institution Project | Found. for Res. in Bronchial Asthma and Related Diseases |
| The Futures Group | University of South Florida | Wayne State University | Weinberg Consulting Group
(Myron Weinberg) |
| Wisconsin Alumni Research Foundation | | | |
| DOUBLE-HIDDEN SPECIAL GRANTS paid through the companies/itself |
|---|
| CTR (paid itself) | Hearings-Kennedy-Hart Bill | Industry Research Liaison Committee | Philip Morris
Thomas S Osdene |
RJ Reynolds
Murray Senkus | |
Sources: http://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/pkg/USCOURTS-dcd-1_99-cv-02496/pdf/USCOURTS=dcd-1_99-cv-02496-4.pdf
See also [5] and this 1972-81 list with the total amounts paid: [6] This is not an exhaustive list.<br The CTR also has a special site with an index under the Minnesota Agreement. (not very useful) [7]
|
These are CTR Special Project grantees now known not to have been included in the above list: [8]
- SP#1 Kurt Enslein, Computers, Uni of Rochester NY
- SP#33 S H Friedall, Cancer Research Inst, New England Deaconness Hospital, Boston.
- SP#42 Doris L Herman, pathologist, Uni of Southern California, Los Angeles(worked with Lyman Brewer.
- SP#44 William H Alban, pathologist, Houston Dept of Public Heath/Baylor Uni (worked with Eleanor MacDonald
- SP#45/63 Douglas M Sprunt, pathologist, Golightly Found. + Uni of Tennessee, College of Medicine, Memphis
- SP#46, SP#24, SP#25, Marcus M Mason, research lab owner, Mason Research Institute, Worcester, Mass
- SP#48 William J Bair, animal inhalation exp., Battelle Memorial Inst, Richland, Washington
- SP#49 David M Kissen psychologist/psychosmatic, Uni of Glasgow, Scotland
- SP#52 Frederick J Stare, Nutrition Dept, Harvard Un (laundering payment for Carl C Seltzer
- SP#53 Travis W Winsor, Memorial Heart Res. Foundation, LA CA
- SP#54 A Clifford Barger, Prof.Emeritus, Harvard Medical School, Boston
- SP#55 Lars T Friberg Karolinska Institute, Stockholm, Sweden (Partner with Rune Cederlof)
- SP#57 Hans Selye, Institute of Exp. Med. and Surgery, Uni of Montreal, Canada
- SP#64 William L Dunn, Philip Morris executive.
- SP#66 Jerome Kleinerman, pathologist, St Lukes Hospital, Cleverland OH/Western Reserve Uni.
- SP#68 ]]H Hugh Fudenberg]], University of California, San Franciso. (Working with John V Wells
- SP#69 Claus B Bahnson, East PA Psychiatric Institute, Philadelphia
References
