Front groups
A front group is an organization that purports to represent one agenda while in reality it serves some other party or interest whose sponsorship is hidden or rarely mentioned. The front group is perhaps the most easily recognized use of the third party technique. For example, the Center for Consumer Freedom (CCF) claims that its mission is to defend the rights of consumers to choose to eat, drink and smoke as they please. In reality, CCF is a front group for the tobacco, restaurant and alcoholic beverage industries, which provide all or most of its funding.
Of course, not all organizations engaged in manipulative efforts to shape public opinion can be classified as "front groups." For example, the now-defunct Tobacco Institute was highly deceptive, but it didn't hide the fact that it represented the tobacco industry. There are also degrees of concealment. The Global Climate Coalition, for example, didn't hide the fact that its funding came from oil and coal companies, but nevertheless its name alone is sufficiently misleading that it can reasonably be considered a front group.
The shadowy way front groups operate makes it difficult to know whether a seemingly independent grassroots is actually representing some other entity. Thus, citizen smokers' rights groups and organizations of bartenders or restaurant workers working against smoking bans are sometimes characterized as front groups for the tobacco industry, but it is possible that some of these groups are self-initiated (although the tobacco industry has been known to use restaurant groups as fronts for its own interests).
History
Edward Bernays, who is generally regarded as the "father of public relations," liked to tell people, "What I do is propaganda, and I just hope it's not impropaganda." In his later years, he became a vocal critic of some of the deceptive techniques used within the PR industry. And yet it is Bernays himself who invented the quintessential tool of deceptive propaganda -- the "front group."
Bernays stumbled on this strategy almost by accident. In 1913, while working as editor of the Medical Review of Reviews, a monthly magazine owned by a college acquaintance, he discovered that the then-famous actor Richard Bennett was interested in producing a play titled "Damaged Goods," which Bernays described as "a propaganda play that fought for sex education." It discussed sexual topics, such as prostitution, that were considered unusually frank for their day. Bennett was afraid that the play would be raided by police, and he hired Bernays to prevent this from happening. Rather than arguing for the play on its merits, Bernays cleverly organized a group that he called the "Medical Review of Reviews Sociological Fund," inviting prominent doctors and members of the social elite to join. The organization's avowed mission was to fight venereal disease through education. Its real purpose was to endorse "Damaged Goods," and apparently the plan worked. The show went on as scheduled, with no interference from police.
"This was a pioneering move that is common today in the promotion of public causes--a prestigious sponsoring committee," notes PR industry historian Scott Cutlip. "In retrospect, given the history of public relations, it might be termed the first effort to use the front or third party technique." It was a technique that Bernays would return to time and again, calling it "the most useful method in a multiple society like ours to indicate the support of an idea of the many varied elements that make up our society. Opinion leaders and group leaders have an effect in a democracy and stand as symbols to their constituency." Bernays helped jump-start sales of bacon, a breakfast rarity until the 1920s, by enlisting a prominent doctor to solicit fellow doctors' opinions on the salutary benefits of a hearty breakfast and by arranging to have famous figures photographed eating breakfasts of bacon and eggs. To sell bananas on behalf of the United Fruit Company, he launched the "celiac project," republishing and disseminating a 20-year-old medical paper which found that eating bananas cured children with celiac disease, a disorder of the digestive system.
"Mr. Bernays has . . . created more institutes, funds, institutions, and foundations than Rockefeller, Carnegie, and Filene together," observed the Institute for Propaganda Analysis, a nonprofit educational organization that flourished in the years following World War I. "Typical of them was the Temperature Research Foundation. Its stated purpose was 'to disseminate impartial, scientific information concerning the latest developments in temperature control as they affect the health, leisure, happiness, and economy of the American people.' A minor purpose--so minor that rarely did Mr. Bernays remember even to mention it--was to boost the sales of Kelvinator refrigerators, air-condition units, and electric stoves."
Examples
For simplicity's sake, the list below includes some organizations (like the Tobacco Institute) that are not front groups per se but that engage in other deceptive activities.
International examples
US examples
- Accuracy in Media
- ActivistCash.com
- The Advancement of Sound Science Coalition
- Africa Fighting Malaria
- African American Republican Leadership Council
- AIDS Responsibility Project
- Air Hygiene Foundation
- Air Quality Standards Coalition
- Alaska's Future
- Alexis de Tocqueville Institution
- Alliance for Better Foods
- Alliance for Quality Nursing Home Care
- Alliance for Responsible CFC Policy
- American Beverage Institute
- American Council on Science and Health
- American Forest Foundation
- American Forest Resource Alliance
- American Industrial Health Council
- American Policy Center
- American Tort Reform Association
- Americans for Tax Reform
- Americans for Balanced Energy Choices
- A.N.S.W.E.R.
- Association for Competitive Technology
- Beverly Hills Restaurant Association
- Black America's PAC
- Borrowsmart.org
- Morton Blackwell Leadership Institute
- California Civil Rights Initiative
- Californians for Statewide Smoking Restrictions
- California Political Empowerment Committee
- Campaign for Working Families
- Capital Research Center
- Center for Consumer Freedom
- Center for the Defense of Free Enterprise
- Center for Environmental Education Research
- Center for Produce Quality
- Center for Union Facts
- Christian Coalition
- Choose Black America
- Citizens Against Lawsuit Abuse
- Citizens' Alliance for Responsible Energy
- Citizens Against Unfair Health Care Taxes
- Citizens for a Free Kuwait
- Citizens for a Sound Economy
- Citizens for Better Medicare
- Citizens for the Environment
- Citizens for Sensible Control of Acid Rain
- Citizens for Sensible Energy Choices
- Clean and Safe Energy Coalition
- Climate Council
- Coalition for Asbestos Resolution
- Coalition for Equal Access to Medicines
- Coalition for Equal Rights
- Coalition for a Fair Judiciary
- Coalition for Fair and Affordable Lending
- Coalition for Health Insurance Choices
- Coalition for Responsible Credit Practices
- Coalition for Southern Africa
- Coalition for Vehicle Choice
- Committee on Taxation and Economic Growth
- Competitive Enterprise Institute
- Community Financial Services Association of America
- Congressional Human Rights Caucus
- Consumer Alert
- Consumers Alliance for Affordable Natural Gas
- Consumer Alliance for Energy Security
- Consumer Credit Research Foundation
- Consumer Data Industry Association
- Consumer Distorts
- Consumer Federation of America
- Consumers Organized for Reliable Electricity
- Consumers' Research
- Consumers for World Trade
- Contributions Watch
- Council for Affordable Health Insurance
- Council for Agricultural Science and Technology
- Council for Solid Waste Solutions
- Council of American Muslims for Understanding
- Council of National Policy
- Council for Energy Independence
- Democracy Watch
- Employment Policies Institute
- Employment Roundtable
- Endangered Species Reform Coalition
- Energy Stewardship Alliance
- Environmental Issues Council
- EPA Watch
- Fairlendingnow.org
- Families Organized to Represent the Coal Economy FORCE
- Farmers for Clean Air and Water
- Financial Services Roundtable
- Foundation for Clean Air Progress
- Foundation for Research on Economics and the Environment
- FreedomWorks
- Global Climate Coalition
- Global Climate Information Project
- Global Warming Cost website
- GreenFacts Foundation
- Greening Earth Society
- Guest Choice Network
- Hands Off the Internet
- Heidelberg Appeal
- Health Benefits Coalition
- Healthcare Leadership Council
- Healthy Buildings International, major Philip Morris contractor
- Heartland Institute
- Hepatitis C Coalition
- Independent Women's Forum
- Information Council for the Environment
- International Freedom Foundation
- Institute for Regulatory Policy
- International Food Information Council
- JunkScience.com
- Keep America Beautiful
- Lake & Peninsula Business Development Center
- Landmark Legal Foundation
- Leipzig Declaration on Global Climate Change
- Maine Conservation Rights Institue
- Manhattan Institute for Policy Research
- George C. Marshall Institute
- Mountain States Legal Foundation
- National Anxiety Center
- National Association of Affordable Housing Lenders
- National Business Coalition on E-Commerce and Privacy
- National Center for Genome Resources
- National Center for Policy Analysis
- National Center for Public Policy Research
- National Consumer Coalition
- National Empowerment Television
- National Endangered Species Act Reform Coalition
- National Endowment for Democracy
- National Environmental Policy Institute
- National Home Equity Mortgage Association
- National Journalism Center
- National Legal Center for the Public Interest
- National Wetlands Coalition
- National Wilderness Institute
- Nestlé Coordination Center for Nutrition
- Nicaraguan Freedom Fund
- No More Scares Campaign
- Non-Smoker Protection Committee
- North American Coalition on Green Building
- Oregon Institute of Science and Medicine
- Partnership to Protect Consumer Credit
- Political Economy Research Center
- Progress & Freedom Foundation
- Project Evergreen
- Project Learning Tree
- Project Protect
- Public Interest Watch
- Railwatch
- Reason Foundation
- Regulatory Impact Analysis Project
- Republicans for Clean Air
- Responsible Industry for a Sound Environment
- Responsible Mortgage Lenders Coalition
- Save Our Species Alliance
- Science and Environmental Policy Institute
- Sea Lion Defense Fund
- Senior Coalition
- Shape the Debate
- Silica Coalition
- Smart Growth Madison
- 60 Plus Association
- Social Issues Research Centre
- Statement by Atmospheric Scientists on Global Warming
- Statistical Assessment Service
- Susan B. Anthony List
- Teacher Choice
- Temperate Forest Foundation
- Torches of Freedom Brigade
- United for Jobs
- United Seniors Association
- Voters for Campaign Truth
- Washington Forest Protection Association
- Washington Legal Foundation
- Water Environment Federation
- Wise Use Movement
- Workplace Health & Safety Council
- Business Tobacco Alliance
Canadian Examples
European & UK Examples
- Agricultural Biotechnology Council
- Associates for Research into the Science of Enjoyment (ARISE)
- British Nutrition Foundation
- CropGen
- European Sound Climate Policy Coalition
- European Science and Environment Forum
- European Security Advocacy Group
- IWMC World Conservation Trust
- Sense About Science
- Scientific Alliance
- World Conservation Trust Foundation
Australian Examples
See also
External links
- http://www.coopamerica.org/individual/marketplace/IMBSRR05.HTM
- "Moving A Public Policy Agenda: The Strategic Philanthropy of Conservative Foundations," National Committee for Responsive Philanthropy, July 1997.