Coca Cola's Misleading "Myth-busting" Ad

In October 2008, Coca-Cola South Pacific Pty Ltd (CCSP) -- the subsidiary company responsible for marketing and technical services for the Coca-Cola products in Australia -- published advertisements titled Kerry Armstrong on Motherhood and Myth-busting in a number of Australian newspapers. (Kerry Armstrong is a high profile Australian actress.) The advertisement prompted complaints to the Australian advertising industry's self-regulatory body, the Advertising Standards Bureau. In November 2008 the ASB di8smissed the complaint.

However, the Australian government's consumer protection agency, the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission, found the advertisement breached laws banning false and misleading advertising and directed the company to take out corrective advertisements in a number of newspapers. Sydney Morning Herald marketing reporter, Julian Lee noted that Coca-Cola's agency, Singleton Ogilvy & Mather, refused to comment. He summarised the outcome of the debacle as "The cost to Coke? Its fee to Kerry Armstrong - about $70,000. The corrective ads - $200,000. And its reputation - priceless."

The original advertisement

The advertisement featured a preamble by Armstrong in which she stated in part that "when I was asked to speak out in favour of one of the world's largest brands, Coca-Cola, it became clear that it was surrounded by all kinds of myths and conjecture. Now that I've found out what's myth and what isn't, it's good to know that our family can continue to enjoy one of our favourite drinks. My boys now call me 'Mun, the Myth Buster!'"

Following Armstrong's premable was a list of "some of the common myths the team at Coca-Cola has recently busted once and for all, so you can decide what to believe for yourself." It listed the myths as being:

• "It's full of added preservatives and artificial colours"
• "Makes you fat"
• "It was originally green"
• "'Coca-Cola contained cocaine once upon a time"
• "Packed with caffeine"
• "Rots your teeth"

Retraction

In April 2009, the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission announced that Coca Cola had agreed to publish corrective advertisements. In the media release announcing CCSP's binding undertakings, the ACCC stated that it believed that "the advertisements had the potential to mislead consumers by representing that:

• Coca-Cola cannot contribute to weight gain and obesity;
• Coca-Cola cannot contribute to tooth decay;
• 250ml of the Coca-Cola Product bearing the brand Diet Coca-Cola contains one half of the amount of caffeine as that contained in 250ml of tea; and
• a responsible parent can include Coca-Cola in a family diet without any regard whatsoever to the potential for weight gain or tooth decay arising from consuming Coca-Cola."

"Coke's messages were totally unacceptable, creating an impression which is likely to mislead that Coca-Cola cannot contribute to weight gain, obesity and tooth decay. They also had the potential to mislead parents about the potential consequences of consuming Coca Cola," the ACCC stated.

Articles and Resources

Related SourceWatch Articles

• Obesity PR
• Using celebrities

Resources

• Coca Cola, "Kerry Armstrong on Motherhood and Myth-busting", Advertisement, October 2008. (Pdf)
• Advertising Standards Bureau, "Case Report: 1. Complaint reference number 443/08 Complaint Coca-Cola South Pacific Pty Ltd", November 12, 2008. (PDf - note the ASB website does not allow a direct link to the report but it can be easily accessed by entering the case number -- 443/08 -- into the case reports search bar.)
• Coca Cola, "Setting the Record Straight", Advertisement, April 2008.

External links

• Craig Sinclair, "Busting Kerry Armstrong's Coca Cola myths", Crikey, October 16, 2008. (Craig Sinclair is the spokesperson for the Parents Jury, a group campaigning on advertising directed at children.)
• Stephen Downes, "Coca-Cola blinks, loses its marketing mojo", Crikey, October 20, 2008.
• Julian Lee, "Kerry Armstrong coke ad gets all-clear", Sydney Morning Herald, November 27, 2008.
• Daniella Miletic, "'Myth-busting' Coke adverts get busted", The Age, April 3, 2009.
• Daniella Miletic and Kelly Burke, "Actor Armstrong breaks silence over misleading Coca-Cola ads", The Age, April 2, 2009.
• Simon Canning, "Coke myth-buster not the real thing", The Australian, April 03, 2009.
• Daniel Wills, "Coke's embarrassing advertising backdown", The Advertiser (Adelaide), April 03, 2009.
• Julian Lee, "Coke debacle bad for industry self-regulation", Sydney Morning Herald, April 4, 2009.